The Kindle Paperwhite is okay, but certainly not ideal

imagesWell, I’ve been using this thing for two weeks now, I think. And it’s pretty good. Gets the most points for the navigation. It’s fairly easy to go back and forth. When you tap a footnote, it doesn’t zoom you over to some other section of the book–the footnote just opens up on top of your document. You can open the table of contents and flick forward or backward to check out what’s around, without ever having to sacrifice your current page.

I like the reading light a lot. It lights up well and evenly and it’s easy to adjust levels. They say you can’t ever turn it completely off, but when you put it to the lowest level, it’s pretty off. However, I’ve found that even when there is some ambient light, it’s often more comfortable to have the reading light on at least a little bit, so there’s more contrast (it helps to alleviate the classic e-reader problem, which is that, since the background is grey and the text is black, it sometimes wearies the eyes.)

I did, however, have to manually recreate my collections, which was awful. It easy took a few hours to do what (by using Calibre) I’d been able to do in a few minutes on the Kobo.

Furthermore, I’ve already experienced major technical glitches. For one thing, I noticed that my battery life was abysmal. I was having to charge it every two or three days. Now, new Kindles often have poor battery life because they’re indexing all the books you put on, so that they’ll be searchable. However, that usually takes a few days, not a few weeks. I eventually realized that the indexing had gotten stuck, so I deleted the index and forced the Kindle to reindex. It continued to get stuck. Most of the time, I managed to get the indexing going again by restarting the Kindle, but eventually it halted entirely.

Finally, I got fed up and decided to just do a factory reset and–from now on–only keep a few books on the Kindle. This is radically different from how I’ve normally done things (normally I like to have a larger number of options as to what to read next), but the alternative was to just accept extremely poor battery life.

However, the latest Kindle update includes the ability to store your collections in the cloud. This has, to a certain extent, made it a bit easier to keep fewer books in the local memory. Using the Kindle device I can (laboriously) arrange all my books into collections and browse through the titles in the cloud. It’s only when I am thinking about actually reading them that I need to tap on them and download them to the mirrored collection in my device’s local memory. And, hopefully, these cloud collections won’t disappear each time I upgrade devices or do a factory re-set.

I hate hate hate hate hate hate the way the Kindle tells you how far you are in the book

I’m reading Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (on a sidenote, I bet that last name really hurts his citation count. Misspellings alone must cost him big time). And it’s pretty excellent. I read it once before, when I found it in my dad’s study. But I was like twelve, so all that I retained of it is that there is this thing called flow (which is where you’re completely lost in an activity and time stops and you feel like the master of time and space and the universe opens up and everything’s amazing).

What I find interesting is that the book has both a normative and a descriptive component. The descriptive part is just describing flow: when it occurs, how to make it occur, what it’s like, etc. The normative part consists of the assertion that flow is “optimal experience”–basically that it’s the best thing ever, and that the purpose of life is to get into flow.

Obviously not a provable assertion, but certainly thought-provoking and more convincing than most philosophical standpoints, because flow is actually extremely pleasurable, but doesn’t have the same downsides as most pleasurable activities. It’s the best kind of pleasure.

I am enjoying the book. It resonates with me. I experience flow fairly regularly, both when I write and when I read.

For years, writing didn’t involve anything even approaching flow. It was actually extremely painful. But now that I’ve gotten better and refined my techniques, I’m operating on a bit of a higher level. And, true to the lessons of the book, I generally get into flow whenever I’m pushing the limits of my abilities.

Anyway, none of that is the point of this article. The point is that at some point the book started talking about your attention and about how, in order to get lost in something, you need to restrict your attention to just the matter at hand. And I realized that I really really really really hate the way the Kindle tells you what page you’re on. I mean, I always knew that I hated it. But now I knew that I really hated it.

kp-slate-05-lg._V358033061_If you don’t use one, then you don’t know: the Kindle has two progress counters. On the left side, there’s a percentage. And on the right side there’s one of four completely arbitrary numbers: time left until you complete the book (based on your reading speed), time left until you complete the chapter, location (a weirdly arbitrary Kindle-centric number that’s usually in the hundreds or thousands), and page number (but this doesn’t refer to actual page turns on your device…it refers to some weird arbitrary page number, so that it might take three or four Kindle page turns to get this number to change).

All of these numbers are awful! It’s like they were put in there by someone who doesn’t actually like to read books.

The time markers are awful because they focus on when you’re going to finish the book, when you’re supposed to be losing track of time.

The location marker is awful because it makes me keep glancing down and performing quick math to see how many page turns it takes to go up how many locations and how many page turns I’ll need to get to some arbitrary location.

And page turn is the worst of all, because it just makes me glance down with each page to see if the page turn number has gone up.

Oh, and don’t get me started on percentage completion. This was the worst of all, because it made me continually do mathematical operations to try to relate this to the other number and to how many page turns it’d take to make the percentage go up.

It took me awhile to figure out why all these number bothered me when the page number on regular books does not.

It’s because the page number on a real book increments in an orderly fashion. You turn the page and the page number goes up. There’s no uncertainty there. You don’t need to keep looking at it, because you know you’re just one page above the last page you were on.

Anyway, I put down the book, got out some tape, and solved the problem. Since tape doesn’t conduct electricity, it doesn’t trigger the Kindle’s capacitative touchscreen and, thus, there’s no problem putting tape on the screen.

2013-11-18 19.47.07